NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL SONG INDEX
| SONG | TYPE |
| A Baby for Pree | album |
| A&E Melody | demo |
| Acid | live |
| Angel Eyes (unconfirmed title) | demo |
| All the Colors of the Rainbow | live |
| April 1st ("Swallowed") | demo |
| April 8th | album |
| Arms So Real | demo |
| Aunt Eggma Blowtorch | single |
| Avery Island / April 1st | album |
| Beautiful Baby (see "Rubby Bulbs") | mislabel |
| Beautiful Face (see "In The Aeroplane Over The Sea") | alt. title |
| Biscuit | demo |
| Bomb Drop (see "Rubby Bulbs") | alt. title |
| Bucket | compilation |
| Calypso Part One | demo |
| Calypso Part Two | demo |
| Candy Coated Dream | demo |
| Carnival (see "untitled ["Ghost" coda]") | alt. title |
| Charlotte | demo |
| Chocolate Coffin | demo |
| Circle of Friends | demo |
| Communist Daughter | album |
| Conversation with Rob Schneider (see "Conversation with Will Hart") | mislabel |
| Conversation with Will Hart | demo |
| Digestion Machine | demo |
| Engine | compilation |
| Everything Is | single |
| Ferris Wheel on Fire | live |
| Follow Me Down (unconfirmed title) | demo |
| Gardenhead / Leave Me Alone | album |
| Ghost | album |
| Glow Into You (see "Where You'll Find Me Now" / "A Baby For Pree") | alt. title |
| Glue | compilation |
| Going Down | demo |
| Goldaline | live |
| Golden Leaf (see "Goldaline") | mislabel |
| Heroin Bag (unconfirmed title) | demo |
| Holland, 1945 | album |
| Hypnotic Sounds (see "Aunt Eggma Blowtorch") | alt. title |
| I Bring Jennifer (see "Jennifer") | alt. title |
| I Hear You Breathe | demo |
| I Love How You Love Me (Phil Spector cover) | live |
| I Will Bury You in Time | live |
| In the Aeroplane Over the Sea | album |
| Invent Yourself a Shortcake | compilation |
| Jaw Harp | demo |
| Jennifer | demo |
| Jesus Christ (see "King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 2") | alt. title |
| King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 1 | album |
| King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 2 | album |
| King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 3 | album |
| Life Is Neverending (unconfirmed title) | demo |
| Little Birds | live |
| Los Angeles | demo |
| Los Angelos Car Song (see "Los Angeles") | alt. title |
| Love You More Than Life | demo |
| Love You on a Tuesday (see "Tuesday Moon") | mislabel |
| Madam Truffle (Major Organ and the Adding Machine) | non-nmh |
| Marching Theme | album |
| Message Sent ("Through My Tears") | demo |
| Mother (John Lennon) | live |
| More Noise | demo |
| My Dream Girl Don't Exist | demo |
| My Dreamgirl (see "My Dream Girl Don't Exist") | alt. title |
| My Skull | live |
| Naomi | album |
| Noisy Racket | demo |
| Nothing's Going To Happen (Tall Dwarfs) | live |
| Now I'm Going Down (see "Going Down") | mislabel |
| Now There is Nothing (unconfirmed title) | demo |
| Oh Comely | album |
| Oh Sister | live |
| Over the Waves (Tall Dwarfs) | non-nmh |
| Piggy | demo |
| Possum Born (Tall Dwarfs) | non-nmh |
| Prank Call | demo |
| Preacherman | demo |
| Pree-Sisters Swallowing a Donkey's Eye | album |
| Rain | live |
| Random Noise | demo |
| Random Noise II | demo |
| Random Noise III | demo |
| Rubby Bulbs | compilation |
| Sailing Through | demo |
| She Did A Lot of Acid (see "Acid") | alt. title |
| Sinking Ship | demo |
| Snow Song, Pt. 1 | single |
| Someone Is Waiting | album |
| Song Against Sex | album |
| Song for Ché (Charlie Haden cover) | live |
| Spooky Sounds | demo |
| Swallowed (see "April 1st") | alt. title |
| Sweet Marie | demo |
| Swimming in your Speakers (unconfirmed title) | demo |
| Synthetic Flying Machine (see "King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 3") | alt. title |
| Tea Time | demo |
| The Arrow Flies Close (Elf Power) | non-nmh |
| The Fool | album |
| The Gifted Children - "Neutral Milk Hotel" | mislabel |
| The Penny Arcade In California (see "untitled ["Ghost" coda]") | alt. title |
| Three Peaches | album |
| Through My Tears (see "Message Sent") | alt. title / mislabel |
| To Animate The Body... (The Long Warm Wall of Alfred Snouts) | non-nmh |
| Tuesday Moon | single |
| Two-Headed Boy | album |
| Two-Headed Boy Pt. 2 | album |
| untitled ("Ghost" coda) | album |
| untitled (Ptolemaic Terrascope No. 21) | compilation |
| Up And Over (see "King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 3") | alt. title |
| Up And Over We Go (see "King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 3") | alt. title |
| What A Wonderful World (Major Organ and the Adding Machine) | non-nmh |
| When The Stars Shine (The Instruments) | non-nmh |
| Where You'll Find Me Now | album |
| Wishful Eyes | demo |
| Wood Guitar | demo |
| Worms In The Wind | live |
| Worms (see "Worms In The Wind") | alt. title |
| You Can Deny All Your Addictions (see "A&E Melody") | mislabel |
| You've Passed | album |
| You've Passed Pt. 2 (unconfirmed title) | live |